Welcome to Plaza Pizza
At Plaza Pizza, we believe in crafting memorable dining experiences steeped in tradition and flavor. Nestled in Newark, OH, our story is about more than just pizza; it’s about family, community, and the joy of sharing delicious food. With a diverse menu featuring options for every palate—including veggie lovers and meat enthusiasts alike—our signature dishes, like the heartfelt Shirley Lou Pizza, pay tribute to our roots. From takeout to outdoor seating, we cater to all dining preferences, ensuring every visit is special. Join us at Plaza Pizza, where every slice tells a story and every meal is a celebration.
- 1130 Mount Vernon Rd 1 Ste 1 Newark, OH 43055 United States Hotline: (740) 366-5627
Welcome to Plaza Pizza, a delightful addition to Newark, Ohio's vibrant food scene. Located at 1130 Mount Vernon Rd, this pizzeria combines classic flavors with creative twists, ensuring a memorable dining experience for all!
At Plaza Pizza, the menu is a pizza lover's paradise. From customizable mini pizzas to larger offerings, there's something for everyone. Their 9" BYO Mini Pizza lets you get creative with toppings like extra cheese, pepperoni, and even anchovies. If you prefer a taste of everything, the All The Way Pizza features a delightful variety of toppings, while the BBQ Chicken Pizza adds a smoky sweetness that certainly excites the palate. For those with a penchant for spice, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza is a must-try, bursting with bold flavors and topped with a drizzle of ranch.
- Family-Friendly: Plaza Pizza is great for kids and offers a warm, inviting atmosphere that's perfect for family gatherings or casual dinners.
- Vegetarian Options: With numerous vegetarian selections, including the delicious Veggie All The Way Pizza, meat-free diners will find plenty to enjoy.
- Convenience: Whether you prefer takeout, delivery, or dining in, Plaza Pizza accommodates all your needs. With waiter service, outdoor seating, and even catering options, they’ve made it easy for you to enjoy their offerings.
- Payment Flexibility: Accepting credit cards and Apple Pay makes it easier than ever to satisfy your pizza cravings.
My personal highlight from Plaza Pizza is the Shirley Lou Pizza, honoring the owner’s grandmother. This innovative dessert pizza is topped with homemade apple pie filling, sweet streusel, and a drizzle of icing — a perfect end to any meal!
With moderate noise levels and accommodations for groups, Plaza Pizza also features on-site parking, Wi-Fi, and TV, adding to the convenience of your visit. Whether you’re dining in with friends, looking for a casual night out, or planning an office catering event, Plaza Pizza has you covered.
Don’t miss your chance to explore the culinary creativity at Plaza Pizza. Their dedication to quality and taste is truly evident in every slice!
For inquiries or to place an order, call (740) 366-5627. Make your next meal a memorable one at Plaza Pizza!

Newarks hidden gem! I crave their thin crust pepperoni. Super friendly staff too they remember your name and your order. Thats rare!

Best pizza in Newark, no competition. Their thin crust is amazing, and the whole staff makes you feel like family.

Plaza Pizza is a hidden gem that every pizza lover needs to experience. From the moment you walk in, youre greeted with the irresistible aroma of freshly baked pizza and a warm, friendly atmosphere. ...

I tried this place on a recommendation, and now Im hooked. Amazing thin crust pizza and such a sweet staff. Newark, youve got a winner here.

Cant say enough good things about Plaza Pizza. The team is so kind, and the pizza is incredible. Thin, crunchy crust with just the right amount of toppings.

I am a thin crust pizza fan, and theirs definitely delivered. I ordered the All The Way, which most places will mound the toppings and can make the crust mushy andor just be overwhelming with toppings. Plaza does a great job of giving ...

Ive been coming here for years. The service is always topnotch, and the pizza? Crispy, cheesy perfection. Definitely the best thin crust in town.

Every bite of this pizza screams quality. Thin crust done right, and the crew here always makes sure you leave happy. Five stars!